Your Brain on ChatGPT: Why AI Should Augment, Not Replace, Leadership

A recent MIT Media Lab study entitled “Your Brain on ChatGPT: Accumulation of Cognitive Debt when Using an AI Assistant for Essay Writing Task” reveals compelling and cautionary insights into how overreliance on AI tools may impact human cognition thetimes.co.uk+11media.mit.edu+11media.mit.edu+11.

What the Study Reveals

Researchers asked 54 participants to write essays in three ways: only with AI assistance via ChatGPT (“LLM group”), using search engines like Google, or unaided (“Brain-only group”). Brain activity was measured using EEG. The results were striking:

• The Brain-only group showed the highest cognitive engagement and memory recall.

• The Search Engine group showed moderate engagement.

• The LLM (ChatGPT) group demonstrated the weakest brain connectivity, suggesting reduced thinking depth and memory retention actu.ai+6media.mit.edu+6arxiv.org+6techlearning.com.

Furthermore, when ChatGPT users were later asked to write without AI assistance, their brains continued to underperform, suggesting short‑term reliance may cause longer-term cognitive dampening appliedai.tools.

The Concept of “Cognitive Debt”

The study introduces the notion of cognitive debt, where outsourcing mental effort to AI tools creates a hidden cost. Over time, individuals may become less capable of deep thinking, memory retention, and original ideas… Even when not using AI arxiv.orgappliedai.tools.

Why This Matters for Leaders

As a leadership coach and keynote speaker, here’s what I see:

1. AI should amplify leadership. Not replace it.

   Great leaders don’t rely solely on technology, they use it to free up time for strategic thinking, connection, and clarity.

2. Future leaders risk stagnating if they don’t evolve.

   Those who default to AI for decision-making or communication may lose mental agility, emotional presence, and creative ownership. Qualities that define magnetic leadership.

3. Tech fluency isn’t enough.

   As OpenAI’s CEO Sam Altman pointed out, his greater concern is how older generations of leaders adapt to AI. Not whether young people can use it fluently businessinsider.com.

Leadership Evolution: Three Key Responses

1. Use AI as a partner, not a crutch

   Treat tools like ChatGPT as assistants. NOT autopilot. Use them to generate ideas, outlines or prompts. Then engage: rewrite, interrogate, customise. The goal is to stay mentally present.

2. Build in reflective practices

   Tools and tech aside, great leaders reflect. After working with AI, pause and ask:

   • What did I add or change?

   • Do I own this output or am I endorsing someone else’s voice?

3. Guard against leadership erosion

   The rarest leadership asset today is not productivity. It’s presence. Leaders who stay mentally sharp, deeply curious, and emotionally authentic will outperform their peers in a world flooded with AI shortcuts.

   
   

My Challenge to You

AI is accelerating. Teams are integrating it daily. But the real risk isn’t AI growing smarter, it’s leaders becoming less sharp in response.

Over the next quarter, I’ll be partnering with executive teams to build next‑gen leadership capacity, anchored by hybrid intelligence training, our Courageous Leaders Framework, Radical Accountability, and Hybrid Neuro‑Mastery coaching that ensures AI enhances, rather than erodes, leadership performance.

Let me know if you’d like to integrate these ideas into an upcoming keynote, workshop, or in‑house training. This is critical work. For teams, for culture, and for sustained performance.

Because AI should serve our best leadership selves… Not substitute them.

---

References:

MIT Media Lab, Your Brain on ChatGPT, 2025 felloai.comNataliya Kosmyna et al., Journal of Cognitive Engagement with LLMs, 2025media.mit.edu+11techlearning.com+11arxiv.org+11Sam Altman interview, Business Insider, Jul 2025 businessinsider.com